The phenomenon of "hit" songs did not really come into
the American consciousness until the 1890's. Of course, the oft mentioned After
The Ball, established a benchmark that all songs that followed were measured
against. Before the 90's, the American music publishing industry was scattered
and ill defined. Hit songs were disconnected and generally regional, save for
a few from early American popular song composers such as Stephen Foster and
Henry Clay Work. It was with the establishment of a central publishing industry,
Tin Pan Alley, and the growth of communication media and later the phonograph
and radio that fostered the idea of nation wide and even world wide hit songs.
This first feature on the subject of hits explores the years from
1890 to 1910 and some of the enduring hits that came from those years. be sure
to see our February, 2002 feature for a review of the decade when hit songs
exploded onto the scene, 1911 - 1920. Also, be sure to see our "In
Search Of" series for articles about the concept of hit songs and what
makes a song successful.
Music by: Reginald De Koven
Lyrics by: Clement Scott
Cover artist: Unknown
Robin Hood premiered on June 9, 1890 in Chicago
and was given Sept. 20 that same year in London at Camden Town Park Hall.
Robin Hood is actually a "light opera" and is still
supposedly popular, but I've never seen nor heard of it being performed
of late. Regardless, this song, and a few others from the opera have endured
as lasting hits that even after 110 years are still routinely heard. It's
most common setting is at weddings where the song has become a perennial
favorite. The beautiful melody and wonderful sentiment have seemingly
tailor made this work for weddings. Oh Promise Me
was actually written in 1889 and was added to "Robin Hood" as
an expediency. Supposedly, De Koven, borrowed the tune from an Italian
piece titled "Musica Proibita". The reason the tune was added
was because the contralto playing Alan-a-Dale (Jesse Bartlet Davis) needed
a song that would properly display her voice.
According to the story, she threatened to walk out on the performance
Koven grabbed a copy of "Oh Promise Me" and gave it to her saving
and the opera and as a result, the song became an immediate hit.
Reginald De Koven (b. Middletown, CT, 1859 - d.
Chicago, IL, 1920) was musically trained in Europe and was a graduate
of Oxford. In 1827 he traveled to Europe and studied piano and composition
in Stuttgart. He earned his degree at Oxford in 1879. During his time
there he also studied with Von Suppé, Delibes, Genée and
Vanuccini, all operatic composers. In 1882 he returned to the US and was
employed primarily as a music critic with Harper's Weekly, The
New York World, Herald and Journal and the
Chicago Evening Post from around 1889 to 1912. He founded and
conducted the Washington (DC) Symphony Orchestra in 1902.
At the same time he was writing and conducting, DeKoven
was composing well over 400 songs, orchestral works, sonatas, ballets
and two grand operas, most of which have faded into obscurity. It is Robin
Hood though, his operetta set in Europe that dominated DeKoven's popularity.
His music draws on both traditional opera as well as folk melodies. Banking
the success of Robin Hood, de Koven later produced Rob Roy(1896),
Highwayman (1897) and Maid Marian in 1901. None of them ever
rose to the
popularity of Robin Hood.
Music by: Henry J. Sayers
Lyrics by: Sayers
Cover artist: unknown
Though a pure American song, written by Sayers in Missouri, the song
was actually introduced in London by Lottie Collins. Collins performed
the song at Koster's and Bial's theaters in New York in 1892 and launched
the song's US success. Over the years, the easily sung and remembered
tune has been claimed by many other composers and lyricists who have added
their own version of the words. Almost all versions after the first, include
extra verses and a "Gentleman's" version that sets the main
character as a man rather than a woman as originally written. Recorded
often, with one recording by the U.S. Marine Corps band, the song has
also been featured in two movies, 1943's Happy Go Lucky and 1947's
Mother Wore tights.
The song has also often been used for many other settings; as a drinking
song, a fraternity song and for many other "made up" occasions.
As a result, I think most people only are familiar with the chorus and
fewer still have ever heard or seen the original lyrics. A bit ribald
yet full of humor and good natured fun, this is the kind of song that
will probably go on for another 110 years and beyond. There has been some
debate even as to Sayers originality with the refrain. Music scholars
have found the tune in an old German songbook. At one point, lawsuits
were filed against various users of the song and Judge Robert Patterson
declared the refrain to be in public domain. In spite of that, a number
of people who laid claim to the song often extorted money from performers
of the song. Cited as a "freak song" by Sigmund Spaeth¹,
it has nonetheless proven to be inextinguishable.
Little is know about Henry J. Sayers beyond his publication of this song.
He was a press agent handling the publicity for a number of performing
companies in 1891 when the song was published. Yet another story related
to the song says that Sayers heard the song performed by "Mamma Lou"
in St. Louis and that she actually wrote it. Sayers supposedly copied
it and had it published therefore earning himself the title of composer.
Originally not a song at all but a piano solo piece, Hearts and Flowers
has become best known and remembered not for the words that were later
added by Mary D. Brine in 1899 that made it a hit song, but for its haunting
melody. That melody has often been used in cartoons and as a sarcastic
symbol of sympathy for those who openly seek it when it seems undeserved.
Most often accompanied by a violin miming, you'll know it instantly when
you hear it. The music was a standard played by silent movie accompanists
for any scene where the heroine was pleading for mercy from the villain.
It is possible that Tobani purloined this entire melody from a work titled
Wintermärchen published in 1891 by Hungarian composer Alphonse Czibulka
as the entire melody is contained in that work. Or, it is possible that
Czibulka took the melody from Tobani as both were originally published
the same year.
Theodore Moses Tobiani (b. Hamburg, Germany, 1855 - d. New York,
1933) though born in Germany, became a notable American composer and arranger.
He was an accomplished violinist who was performing in concert by age
ten. His family brought him to the USA when he was a child but he later
returned to Europe to further his musical education. In 1870 he returned
to the US and worked as a composer and performer in various theaters in
Philadelphia. Tobiani composed over 550 works and made over 4500 arrangements!
Many of his works were arranged or published under the pseudonyms Florence
Reed, Andrew Herman and Theodore Moses. Of all his works, Hearts and Flowers
is is only enduring original popular song composition however, his band
arrangements continue to be played at traditional band concerts
Music by: Chas B. Lawlor
Lyrics by: James W. Blake
Cover artist: Unknown
Songs about New York abound and this is one that has been around since
the sidewalks were dirt! Still heard regularly, the song was used as the
campaign song for Alfred E. Smith, Democratic nominee for President in
the 1924 campaign. It was first introduced at the Old London Theater in
the Bowery of New York City by Lottie Gilson, a popular singer of the
day. As with all of the songs featured this month, it enjoyed a long recording
history. Betty Grable sang it with June Haver in the 1945 film, The
Dolly Sisters and Jimmy Durante and Bob Hope sang it in the 1957
film about Mayor Jimmy Walker, Beau James. A lovely waltz, it
is in the same vein as the Great Daisy Bell (Bicycle built for two) and
the two songs are often heard together. This song was one of the new publishing
house of Howley, Haviland & Co.'s first publications and helped to
establish them as a flourishing publisher. It was one of their most profitable
Charles B. Lawlor was part of a vaudeville team including James
Thornton. The lyricist, James Blake was a salesman in a hatter's
shop who liked to write verses. Lawlor, described as a "buck and
wing" performer² and amateur composer also had written some
verses about New York. Lawlor whistled the original tune to Blake, who
took their combined ideas and created the full lyrics we know today. The
two convinced Gilson to perform the song and it is said that the audience
became so enchanted that they joined her in singing a repeat of the chorus.
As with many of the lasting hits, it is the choruses that are most remembered.
Very few people have heard the full verse and choruses so we are pleased
to present the complete songs and lyrics to you through the scorch presentation
Music by: Chas. B. Ward
Lyrics by: John F. Palmer
Cover artist: unknown
This song was first performed by the composer, Charles Ward in his own
vaudeville act in 1895 at Hammerstein's Harlem Opera House. Long a favorite,
it's lilting waltz melody and chorus are the kind of tunes that "stick
in your head" and make for a lasting hit. Again, we have a song where
mostly we recall the chorus but the fascinating verses are often not heard.
Be sure to get your scorch player to ensure full enjoyment. As with all
lasting hits, this one appeared in several films including a performance
by James Cagney and Rita Hayworth in The Strawberry Blonde in 1941 and
Dennis Morgan in Cattle Town in 1951. Perhaps it's biggest hit recording
was the 1941 version by Guy Lombardo and his Orchestra on Decca. This
song enjoys the status of being the first song ever promoted by newspaper,
the New York World. It sold over one million copies then, and
millions since. Clearly, the publishers were learning how to "hype"
their wares and generate interest and sales by this time.
Charles B. Ward ( 1865 - 1917) was born in London and composed
at least one other enduring hit during his life, Strike Up The Band, also
in 1895. He died in New York in 1917. I've been unable to find any information
about the lyricist, John F. Palmer.
Music by: Joe Hayden
Lyrics by: Theo. A. Metz
Cover artist: unknown
By 1896, Tin Pan Alley was well established and beginning to crank out
plenty of hits, short-term and enduring ones. Though public tastes were
still evolving and "classical" works still held sway in many
homes, popular song was taking hold as the predominant music form heard
in America. Coon
songs, or songs using contrived black dialect were quite popular and
this song used that fashion to send it to the top of the charts in 1896.
Again, we have a song where the chorus is what we recall and the verses
are rarely heard. We also have seen many of the songs "sanitized"
from their original form through the elimination of the offensive stereotype
dialect. I suspect most people who sing these songs today are completely
unaware of their original form or lyric structure. The first recording
of this song was in 1897 by the ragtime singer, Lew Spencer. Teddy Roosevelt's
Rough Riders used this song as their "theme song" during the
battle of San Juan Hill, probably one of the first uses of a popular song
in this manner.
Theodore H. Metz (b. Hanover, Germany, 1848 - d. New York, 1936)
was the bandleader for a popular minstrel group, the McIntyre and Heath
Minstrels who first introduced the song (hence the coon song structure).
¹ A History of Popular Music in America, p. 258.
² All The Years Of American Popular Music, p. 115
See our resources page
for a complete bibliography of all resources used to research this and other
articles in our series.
WAIT! There are more Enduring Hit masterpieces
to see and hear. The second part of this issue features more rare and different
The Parlor Songs Academy is an educational website, designated by the "ac" (academic) domain
If you would like to submit an article about America's music for us to publish, go to our submissions page for information about writing articles for us. We also welcome suggestions for subjects for future articles.
Please Help Us Continue our Efforts with a donation. The Parlor Songs Academy. is a Tennessee unincorporated association. Donations go towards the aquisition of additional music, preservation of music, equipment and educational efforts. If you like what we do, please help us out. Donation funds are used entirely for the operating expenses of Parlor Songs and/or aquisition of additional music or equipment.